When Coping Mechanisms Become Unhealthy: Signs, Examples & Mental Health Effects

Many people turn to the same habits when life gets hard. They might scroll for hours, avoid a hard conversation, or stay busy enough not to feel it. At first, these habits offer real relief. But over time, some of them turn into unhealthy coping mechanisms, strategies that silence stress in the short term but make it worse down the line.

Maladaptive coping mechanisms are changeable, though. They’re learned habits, not fixed traits, which means new ones can be developed in their place with the right kind of support. Knowing what unhealthy coping mechanisms look like, why your brain uses them, and what actually helps is the first step to lasting relief.

This guide will cover:

  • The difference between healthy and unhealthy coping.
  • Common examples of unhealthy coping mechanisms.
  • The signs you’re relying on unhealthy coping skills.
  • How unhealthy coping affects mental health.
  • Healthy alternatives and where to find support.
Facial appearance changes linked to depression and stress
Table of Contents

Healthy vs Unhealthy Coping Mechanisms

Coping mechanisms are thoughts and behaviors people use to manage stress.[1] Not all of them work in the same way.

Adaptive, or healthy coping, includes things like problem-solving, seeking out social support, and reframing a setback in a more workable way. Negative coping mechanisms are associated with poorer mental health outcomes and more severe symptoms overall. They tend to involve avoidance, disengagement, or emotional suppression rather than addressing the stressor. 

Avoidance, in particular, appears across a wider range of mental health conditions, including post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), anxiety, and depression.[1]

That doesn’t mean unhealthy coping only shows up once things reach a crisis point. One study modeled how healthy and unhealthy coping relate to each other. At low distress levels, people mostly lean on self-soothing and social support. As distress builds and becomes overwhelming, unhealthy strategies become common.[2]

Even then, healthy coping doesn’t disappear.[2] Instead, unhealthy strategies seem to add on top of healthy ones that are already stretched thin. Unhealthy coping is often less about a bad habit and more about a stressor outgrowing the coping resources currently available.

For example, watching your favorite TV show to decompress isn’t inherently a problem. Using it every night to avoid a conversation that needs to happen is different.

Another way to think about it is that healthy coping is like a shock absorber. It’s built to flex when you hit a bump in the road. Unhealthy coping mechanisms are closer to slamming on the brakes every time and hoping the road stays flat from now on.

Common Unhealthy Coping Mechanisms Examples

Unhealthy coping mechanisms rarely look dramatic from the outside. Here’s what they might look like in your own daily life.

Avoidance and Withdrawal

Avoidance coping is multidimensional. Research distinguishes passive avoidance, such as resignation and withdrawal, from active avoidance, like distraction or deliberately turning attention elsewhere.[3] Of the two, passive avoidance carries the higher cost.

Resignation and withdrawal are the strongest predictors of perceived stress among coping styles tested, while more active diversion showed little relationship to stress at all.[3]

Avoidance works like putting a bill in a drawer instead of opening it. The immediate stress goes away, but the balance due is still there, growing.

Withdrawal alone is more complicated than it looks. One large study found that withdrawal by itself wasn’t significantly linked to depression. Prolonged social isolation, not solitude in general, predicted worse outcomes. The association was stronger the longer the isolation lasted.[4]

Some people who pull back from others describe genuine relief, not decline.[4] The difference seems to be duration and degree. Withdrawal on its own wasn’t linked to worse outcomes, but isolation lasting three years or more consistently was.

Substance Use, Emotional Eating, and Self-Blame

A few other unhealthy coping mechanisms appear time and time again in research:

  • Substance use: Among people receiving psychiatric care in one study, emotion-focused coping was directly associated with higher addiction risk across cigarette, hookah, and amphetamine use. Meanwhile, task-focused, problem-solving coping was protective. Together, these coping styles accounted for about 35 percent of the difference in addiction-risk scores between people.[5]
  • Emotional eating: This means eating to manage your mood rather than hunger. During the COVID-19 pandemic, emotional eating rates reached roughly 48-76 percent across several international samples. It tracked closely with rising depression and anxiety during that period, too. One study went further, identifying emotional eating as a key link between depression and obesity.[6]
  • Self-blame and denial: Research shows that denial, disengagement, self-blame, and substance use are common maladaptive coping strategies. They tend to cluster into a single coping approach among young adults working through overlapping crises.[7]

None of these behaviors are unusual, and none of them make you weak-willed. They’re common, learnable responses to stress. The next step is learning to recognize them before they deepen.

Signs You’re Relying on Unhealthy Coping Skills

A few patterns tend to appear together, and the signs make it easier to catch unhealthy coping skills in yourself.
    • Coping skills offer fast relief instead of addressing the problem: Rumination, catastrophizing, self-blame, and attributing distress to others are considered maladaptive cognitive strategies. These strategies show up especially often with anhedonic depression, or a lack of interest or pleasure in things that were once enjoyed.[8]
      • They happen on autopilot: You turn to them before you’ve consciously decided to, often within seconds of the stress hitting.
        • They spill into multiple areas of life: A rough week at work turns into skipped meals, lost sleep, and less time for the people you care about. The coping response outlasts whatever triggered it.
        By contrast, the same research found that healthy strategies, seeing a situation differently or refocusing on a plan, appeared alongside milder symptoms. This was especially true for people with anhedonic depression.[8] These signs are important, especially in combination. The more that appear together, the more they tend to shape mental health.
        ARE YOU OR A LOVED ONE STRUGGLING WITH MENTAL HEALTH?

        AMFM is here to help you or your loved one take the next steps towards an improved mental well-being.

        insurancegirl | AMFM Treatment

        How Unhealthy Coping Mechanisms Affect Mental Health

        The link between coping mechanisms and mental health tends to compound over time. In the young-adult crisis study mentioned above, 82 percent reported high levels of uncertainty about the future and 27.5 percent scored above the cutoff for severe anxiety. Over 10 percent met criteria for severe depression.[7]

        Emotional coping around food or substances follows a similar pattern. The behavior briefly eases a difficult emotion. That relief reinforces the habit, but the stressor underneath stays unaddressed, and often gets worse.[6][5]

        Emotion-focused coping around substances follows the same general pattern and is consistently linked to higher addiction risk, though the evidence there is correlational, not a cause-and-effect loop.[5]

        These harmful coping behaviors are more than psychological. Maladaptive coping is associated with higher rates of health-risk behaviors like smoking and drinking, and more severe symptoms in conditions like hypertension.[1] Mental and physical health rarely stay separated for long once an unhealthy coping habit takes hold.

        The right professional support makes a real difference. A review of coping strategies found that asking for support was the most common strategy overall. It came up in 60 percent of the studies reviewed, with physical activity close behind.[9] 

        The same review found that people using active, engagement-oriented coping consistently fared better than those using avoidance or substances.[9]

        Healthy Alternatives to Unhealthy Coping Behaviors

        Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is one of the best-studied behavioral health treatment approaches for unhealthy coping behaviors. It works, in part, by helping people drop avoidant and safety-seeking behaviors. These are the ones that prevent them from testing out whether their fears are true.[10]

        Research on CBT across mental and physical health conditions found it effective for anxiety, depression, and stress-related disorders, at least in the short term. Techniques range from cognitive restructuring to structured exposure and mindfulness-based approaches. Digital and mobile-based CBT programs are increasingly available, too, which offer wider access beyond traditional in-person therapy.[10]

        Having more than one coping strategy helps, too. University students who combined several strategies rather than relying on one narrow habit reported more confidence in their ability to cope than those with fewer strategies.[11] 

        The goal isn’t to eliminate every form of distraction or self-protection. It’s to have more than one tool available, so a stressor doesn’t always cause harm.

        Find Anxiety Treatment Programs

        A Mission For Michael (AMFM) provides treatment for adults experiencing various conditions. Anxiety support is a phone call away – call 866-478-4383 to learn about our current treatment options.

        See our residences in SoCal’s Orange & San Diego Counties.

        Take a look at our Metro area homes in Washington County.

        View our facilities in Fairfax County, VA within the DC metro area.

        View our facilities in Kitsap County, WA 20 miles west of Seattle.

        Identify and Change Unhealthy Coping Mechanisms With AMFM Mental Health Treatment

        At AMFM Mental Health Treatment (A Mission for Michael), our mental health treatment programs are built around this kind of skill-building. We can help you identify the coping patterns that aren’t serving you, understand what those patterns have been protecting you from, and practice healthier alternatives in a structured, supportive environment.

        Our team of expert clinicians believes in treatment persistence and will personalize your treatment plan so you can achieve lasting, life-changing outcomes.

        We offer an intimate, focused mental health treatment experience for adults in home-like settings that are carefully maintained to be peaceful, comfortable spaces. In addition to residential treatment, AMFM Mental Health Treatment also offers multiple levels of outpatient treatment.

        Our locations in California, Minnesota, Virginia, and Washington accept insurance and are in-network with many major providers. To check your insurance coverage for mental health care, simply complete our confidential online verification form.

        Call us at 866-478-4383 if you would like to start the admissions process or learn more about how we can support your mental well-being. Our compassionate team is available 24/7 to answer your questions and provide guidance with no obligation.

        100% Confidential

        No Commitment

        Instant Results

        At AMFM, we strive to provide the most up-to-date and accurate medical information based on current best practices, evolving information, and our team’s approach to care. Our aim is that our readers can make informed decisions about their healthcare.

        Our reviewers are credentialed medical providers specializing and practicing behavioral healthcare. We follow strict guidelines when fact-checking information and only use credible sources when citing statistics and medical information. Look for the medically reviewed badge on our articles for the most up-to-date and accurate information.

        If you feel that any of our content is inaccurate or out of date, please let us know at info@amfmhealthcare.com